Lies and Whispers Part 2: The Apartheid Myth

A favourite mantra of the BDS gangsters and other Israel-bashers, is the lie that Israel is an apartheid state. This is blatant intellectual dishonesty, based on the assumption that the use of the emotive term “apartheid” will elicit the same knee-jerk reaction that was forthcoming whenever South Africa was mentioned in this context.

And yet no two states could be more different! In South Africa, under the apartheid regime, non-whites were prohibited from serving in Parliament, from voting, from serving as judges, from studying in the same schools and universities as whites, from eating in the same restaurants, attending the same cultural events, even from swimming on the same beaches or sitting on the same park benches! Non-whites could not be treated in “white” hospitals, ride on “whites-only” buses or drink from “whites-only” water-fountains. Interracial sex was also a criminal offence, punishable by a long prison term.

NONE of this is true of Israel. We have Arab judges, including one on the bench of the Israeli Supreme Court – Judge Salim Joubran. In May of this year, Judge Joubran was appointed head of Israel’s Central Elections Committee, which oversaw the country’s municipal elections last month.

We have Arab Knesset members – and have done so since the very first Knesset, in 1949. There have also been Arab and Druze cabinet ministers.

There has been an Arab Miss Israel – Rana Raslan, who represented Israel in the 1999 Miss Universe Contest:

Ten years later, a mixed Arab-Jewish duo, Mira Awad and Ahinoam Nini (Noa) represented Israel in the 2009 Eurovision Song Contest.

Jews and Arabs study together at the same universities. Go into any cafe in downtown Jerusalem on a summer afternoon and you will see Jewish and Arab families enjoying iced coffee at adjacent tables. Go into any of the public parks and you will see Jewish and Arab families picnicking on the same lawns. Visit any of Tel Aviv’s golden beaches and you will find Arab holiday-makers enjoying the sun and the waves side by side with Jewish Israelis and with foreign tourists.

Nor is it true that Arabs are prohibited from living in “Jewish” areas, as some anti-Israel bloggers, blinded by a pathological hatred of “the Zionist entity” (Richard Silverstein, for example), have insisted. In my own apartment block, for example, I have Arab residents above and below me – two apartments out of ten. That’s 20% – approximately the proportion of Arab citizens of Israel.

As for the “segregated buses” – take a ride on any bus in Israel and you will see Arabs and Jews sitting side by side.  But this myth is a prime example of how a deliberately misleading headline by a newspaper with an extreme Left-wing agenda, can set in motion a lie that, taken up and repeated by anti-Israel websites and blogs, as well as by mainstream media around the world, within a very short time becomes what Jane Austen might ironically describe as “a truth universally acknowledged” (much like the myth of “illegal Israeli settlements”).  Ha’aretz, which, while always being left-leaning, did once have a modicum of journalistic integrity, came out with the following headline earlier this year:

“Israel introduces ‘Palestinian only’ bus lines, following complaints from Jewish settlers”

But examination of the facts reveals a very different picture. Besides the “national” bus company, Egged, there are a number of smaller, private bus companies, servicing the Jewish towns and villages in Judaea and Samaria and connecting them with central Israel. For obvious security reasons, these companies do not enter Arab villages – but there is no law preventing the Arab villagers from taking a long detour and travelling to one of the Jewish communities, to catch buses there – on the assumption that they have permits to enter Israel (by “Israel”, I mean, the area within the so-called “Green Line”, ie. Israel in its pre-Six Day War boundaries).  The bus company in question, Ofakim, inaugurated two new routes, running directly from “West Bank” Arab villages into central Israel. No-one is forcing the Arab villagers to travel on those buses and they are at liberty, if they so desire, to travel – at further expense – to one of the Jewish communities and catch a bus there. Apartheid? Segregation? That may appear to be the effect, but what would the Israel-bashers and the Bleeding Hearts Liberals prefer? That the new bus lines be abolished and that the Arab villagers be forced to make long detours in order to catch a bus at a more distant stop, merely to gratify the Loony Left and ensure that the requisite Politically Correct “integration” is achieved? Or perhaps they would like to force the Israeli “settlers” to travel to the Arab villages and catch the bus there, in order to achieve that aim? (In fact, I suspect that this is exactly what they would like, since their ultimate goal, of forcing the Jewish “settlers” out entirely, seems – for the time being, at least – doomed to failure.)

And finally – the lie about the “Apartheid Wall”, which, if you believe the Loony Left, is a 700 kilometre , 9-metre high monstrosity made of reinforced cement and barbed wire, twice as long and three times as high as the Berlin Wall.  Now, even if this were true, it would hardly be evidence of an apartheid regime. But it is not true.  Despite the well-publicised photos of a few “hot spots” where the wall actually is a wall, designed to prevent sniper fire, (photos which are recycled ad nauseam by Israel’s enemies), in point of fact, for most of its length it is not a wall, but a chain-link barrier. Despite that, it has done its job by greatly reducing incidences of terrorism in Israel.

Now that we have these facts straight, it is time to examine the real motives and aims of the BDS gangsters. But that, my friends, is another story and will have to wait for another time.

Shabbat Shalom from Jerusalem.

About Shimona from the Palace

Born in London, the UK, I came on Aliyah in my teens and now live in Jerusalem, where I practice law. I am a firm believer in the words of Albert Schweitzer: "There are two means of refuge from the sorrows of this world - Music and Cats." To that, you can add Literature. To curl up on the sofa with a good book, a cat at one's feet and another one on one's lap, with a classical symphony or concerto in the background - what more can a person ask for?
This entry was posted in Politics and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

17 Responses to Lies and Whispers Part 2: The Apartheid Myth

  1. It’s important to clarify that the Arab villagers who need permits to enter Israel are not Israeli citizens. They self-identify as Palestinian and most hold Jordanian citizenship.

  2. ShimonZ says:

    Shabbat Shalom to you, dear Shimona. I can’t understand where you find the strength to try and fight these lies. They have worn me out, and I just ignore them. But I do appreciate those for whom the truth matters.

  3. Kate says:

    I think the problem is mixing up a simile/metaphor with a metonym
    I found a link
    smt.uchicago.edu/glossary2004/metaphormetonym.htm
    A metonym has something in common with for example calling man working on a farm,a hand,so you have something in common with SA in that you havea more than one race/nationality./group of people whp identify under some name
    but it’s not a perfect metaphor because you have all the differences you have pointed out above,
    It’s like me saying I had a nasty lover with green eyes then i shall never love a man with green eyes again.It might put me in danger as all men can be nasty

  4. Kate says:

    And blue eyed men are more aggressive going by the history since WW!…
    Aryans have blue eyes and fair hair and that’s who Hitler liked

  5. Mary says:

    We had a programme on TV showing he was genetically more Jewish than anything else….
    but he was a mixture of various races.

  6. Carolyn says:

    People like your good self have been trying to get the truth out for a very long time. But reasoned discussion has been replaced by visceral unreasonable hatred! The discussion as to why I feel could fill many books!

  7. Pingback: Moving the Goal Posts: Further Thoughts on the “Apartheid Israel” Lie | THE VIEW FROM THE PALACE

  8. Mary says:

    No,you and a friend Silke doubted a friend’s of mines motive for asking you some questions.You are too aggressive for us even though we were sympathizers prior to reading your blog.iThe biggest problem in Europe is a lack of interest in the question,

  9. Pingback: Fighting the Lies: The Phony Holocaust-Naqba Equation | News and Views from Jews Down Under

  10. Pingback: maillot pas cher

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s